The toes are scuffed, and I've colored them in with a black pen. I think it's unnoticeable from a distance. Also, part of the Velcro strap is torn. This is also hidden when the Velcro is fastened. Please refer to the photos. I'll give it to someone who doesn't mind. Black formal shoes with ribbons, size 16.0. - Brand: Catherine Cottage - Color: Black - Design: With ribbon - Size: 16.0 - Style: Formal shoes Thank you for looking.