These are black formal shoes with ribbons from HARUTA. The ribbons are removable, but I always used them without taking them off. I purchased these used and wore them only 2 or 3 times before my child outgrew them. My child likes them so much that we'll buy the next size up. There are some minor scratches and scuffs from the time of purchase, but I considered them acceptable and used them. Please understand that these are children's shoes, so please consider this before purchasing. - Brand: HARUTA - Model Name: KIDS - Color: Black - Design: With Ribbon - Style: Formal Shoes Please feel free to ask if you have any questions. Thank you for looking.