This is a set of three different Clayge cleansing balms, perfect for removing makeup. Purchased in September 2025. As shown in the photo, only the gray Moist type was tested on the back of my hand. The others have only been opened and not used. There is no spatula. The cases have some scratches from storage. I use the black type of this product, and I really like it because it feels light and leaves my skin feeling refreshed and moisturized after washing. - Brand: CLAYGE - Product Name: Cleansing Balm - Type: Makeup Remover - Types: Moist N - Types: Cleansing Balm V - Quantity: Set of 3 Thank you for looking.