I purchased all four of these items new and unused. Due to my child's leg size, they quickly outgrew them, so each item was worn approximately five times. The light pink cherry-patterned item has a tie closure, and the button placement is different. Also, this one has some black spots, even though it was only worn about three times. Please be aware of this. I am also selling other baby items. I can combine shipping, which will save on postage, and I can offer a discount.