"Defective" - There are some minor scratches on the outside of the case, but there are no issues with use. Please check the photos. [Ranked in the rankings] [Free Shipping] Carbon-style, Personal [for 3] Silver Hanko Case Hanko Case Stamp Case Personal Stamp Case Cosmetic Case Compatible with 10.5mm to 18.0mm Personal Stamp Dedicated Case Gift for Individuals [Carbon-style, Personal Cosmetic Case [for 3]: Silver]