I purchased this controller and silicone case new at Geo on Saturday, June 24, 2023. I used the controller a few times with the silicone case attached, and then stopped using it, storing it carefully. As you can see in the 11th image of the silicone case, there are some scuff marks. These marks occurred when I was using it with another controller, just from normal use. Other than that, it's in very good condition. ⚠️ Price is slightly negotiable. Please feel free to comment if you have any questions. Thank you for viewing.