This is a commemorative medal, not for sale, that I redeemed through Club Nintendo. After redeeming it, I stored it in a dark place without ever opening it. Although it is an unopened item, the surface vinyl shows some deterioration of the tape. The black spots in the center of the pins are likely from the deterioration of the cushioning material inside, and do not appear to be scratches on the pins themselves. I will discount the shipping cost if you purchase it together with other goods. Please feel free to contact me.