I bought these a few years ago! As you can see in the photos, I've used the CANMAKE one a bit! The Etude House glitter is mostly unused, but the adhesive that holds the eyeshadow to the case has come to the surface due to deterioration. The glitter itself seems to be fine! I'm also selling these separately, so feel free to comment if you have any questions! Set of CANMAKE eyeshadow palette and Etude House glitter eyeshadow. - Brand: CANMAKE - Product Name: Perfect Stylist Eyes - Color: 05 - Type: Eyeshadow Palette - Additional Item: Glitter Eyeshadow Thank you for looking.