Even in extreme cold, it's rated for 0°C, so even with the tear, I don't feel there's a particular problem with the cold protection, but please refrain from purchasing if you are concerned about the tear (photo 6) or the very stiff zipper on one side. Size: XL Black mesh cycling shoe covers with windbreak function. - Brand: PEARL IZUMI - Color: Black - Features: Windbreak function - Design: Mesh material - Application: Cycling shoe covers Thank you for viewing.